Trade Volstad or Dempster for Qualls

[CarolinaMudcat]

I am newbie so if I do not provide enough info let me know. I am in a NL only points keeper league. My roster is: doumit, r C
Iannita, C C
Lee, D. 1st
Dewitt, B. 2nd
Gonzalez, A(Nats) SS
Tejada, M. MI
Prado, M. 3rd
Infante, O. CI
Hairston, S. OF/ Kearns, A OF
Henske, E. OF/Hauffpair, M OF
Maybin, C. OF/Morgan, N OF
Pitchers: Volstad, C/Dempster, R/Duke, R/Zito, B/Correia, K/ Pelphrey, M/Happ/ Nolasco, R/Kou, H
I have. ZERO saves.
My roster not exactly setting the world on fire. I have been offered Qualls for Volstad straight up or Qualls for Dempster and a draft pick. The person offering just lost Carpenter and also has Bruxton. Is this fair value?

[HOOTIE]

Qualls for Volstad easy.