Trade My Hart and R.Hernandez for Inge and Big Papi? WHIR

[Justblaze]

I am pretty big on Hart, but Ortiz is a game changer when he is on. Although he is quite the opposite of that right now. You guys think I should accept this deal, or you guys think Papi is not gonna bounce back after a horrid beginning of the season?


10 team 5x5 roto: Re-draft, EVERYONE STARTS EXCEPT 6 RESERVES

C:B.Molina,Inge
1B:Howard
2B:Kelly Johnson
3B:Chipper
SS:Tejada
MI:Hudson
CI:Beltre
OF:Hamilton,Holliday,Granderson,Hart,Victorino
U:Hermida

SP:Harden, Vazquez,Cain,Scherzer
RP:Lidge,Qualls,Lindstrom,Gregg,Corpas

Reserves: A-rod, Mauer,Ankiel
Reserves: Lackey,Millwood, Big Unit

[sigriffey]

Hard to say ... I see Inge cooling off and Hernandez being ok in that bandbox. I would say proceed with caution with Papi. No more manny to protect him (look what manny is doing for orlando hudson...). I am not a huge hart guy, but i would say look at how your steals situation is and go from there, because papi will be better than this but it's probably a question of what you lose from hart more than anything else. sorry if that is wishy washy. hope it helps somewhat. i would probably lean away from this deal, but if you like risks, papi has that game changing ability...

[HOOTIE]

Keep Hart

[PeteDog13]

I'm taking the deal. If you have a chance to get a game changer like Papi, especially for that package, you do it.

[mac-unit]

I wouldn't do this. I think Hernandez will do better then Inge this season. And I wouldn't be so sure Papi will out preform Hart over the year.

[irish158]

I would stay put. I think Papi is a shell of himself and he will only regress from this point on.

I wouldn't do the trade.

Thanks for the help on mine...