3 for 3 Mega Trade!

[bigsilkysmooth]

Help me out on this one. Been trying to land Reyes since draft night, this is the only offer he is willing to do......too much of a drop off at 2B? Is Holiday really going to be that much better than Markakis? Will Rollins get it going soon?

I Give:
J. Rollins (SS)
I. Kinsler (2B)
N. Markakis (OF)

I Get:
J. Reyes (SS)
D. Uggla (2B)
M. Holiday (OF)

[henketime]

I think you're giving up WAY TOO much just for Reyes. I am also a Rollins owner and so far the general consensus seems to be that he will eventually turn it around. And you're losing huge in terms of Uggla for Kinsler and Markakis for Holliday (although many do see Holliday turning it around, Markakis is better and a much safer choice).

[Auronx62]

I would not do this deal. he's obviously trying to take advantage of the fact that you want reyes very badly. dont give in to it. its really not worth it. Kinsler's a beast and i dont think uggla can fill in his shoes. holliday not in coors field = no thanks. if you look at it this way, lets just assume that reyes cancels out rollins. so nows its kinsler + Markakis for Holliday + Uggla. That is not an equation that adds up. not int he least bit. tell him he needs to raise the bar, or else i think you're better off without reyes.

[bigsilkysmooth]

I rejected his offer and he has came back with another one....any thoughts?

I Get:
J. Reyes
C. Hamels
J. Johnson

I Give:
J. Rollins
N. Markakis
R. Dempster