Granderson > than Votto, right?

[Lsquad]

I was shopping for a 2 for 1, when someone came back at me with one the other way, his loney and granderson for my votto. I don't like the two for one idea, but I figure granderson is worth more that Votto anyway, right? So Is it a no brainer to offer him back just Votto for Granderson, or should I take Loney to and drop Harang, young, or swisher?

heres my squad:

c: innetta
1b: fielder
2b: utley
3b: Beltre (trade pending)
ss: Hanley
of: Rios
of: ellsbury
of: swisher
util: Votto
util: Tulowitzki
bn: chris young
dl: arod

sp: haren
sp:billingsley
rp: gozalez
rp: Sherrill
P: grienke
p: vazquez
p: hernadez
bn: gallardo
bn: kazmir
bn: harang

btw, its h2h and the extra categories are h, tb, and ks for hitters.

[scorched03]

this early in the season, i use espn draft averages til abt a month into the season.

ppl hyped up votto saying he could go for 35+ HR. if he does that, i wouldnt do it.
Loney can get u 15-25 by himself potentially. and granderson is around the same, so it improves ur depth alot without using the avg sinkhole called chris young.

i'd do it but... u really need another closer than anything

[Snakes Gould]

yeah id do it as well. take loney over young.


i was offered a similar trade for votto last week, but i was offered hart and loney.