Furcal/Duke for his Harden/Smoltz

[gmq]

6x6 roto keeper.. No keepers involved, though. I need pitching, he needs a SS w/ SBs. I have both to spare. He has pitching to spare. Which side has more value?

[gmq]

this is sort of imminent, if i could grab a few opinions quickly to gather some sort of consensus, god bless ya!

[bazzy_51]

without seeing a roster i say straight value no... you lose... Furcal when healthy is a top 5 SS, Duke and Smoltz is a wash... and Harden is obviously injury prone, when healthy great value but how long will health last? if you have a very valid SS behind Furcal then yes cuz i would rather gamble on Harden's health then Furcal's cuz i think he can give you better stats, but base off of value its a no for me...

help me out...
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=379036

[gmq]

I have HanRam.

[gmq]

How about if I make it DeRosa instead of Duke. DeRosa is riding my bench. On straight value, Furcal/DeRosa for Harden/Smoltz

[gmq]

Other opinions? This guy is about to bail negotiations on me!

[gmq]

bump

[Spectrum]

Harden's probably getting hurt. You have no idea what you're getting from Smoltz. But, that said, I'd rather have two half seasons from both of those than a full season from Duke.

If you've got hanley, you don't need Furcal, but I'd sure like to do better than this in a trade, if that's your reasoning...Furcal is worth more than just a throw in/deal maker.

viewtopic.php?t=379109