Lincecum/Jiminez for Quentin/Shields

[sreill]

I get Quentin and shields i give up Lincecum and Jiminez

Any opinions?


Ianetta
Berkman
Phillips
Hardy
Beltre
Beltran
Murphy/Burrell
Carlos Lee
Delgado


Johan
Lincecum
Pelfry
Jiminez
Billingsley

[bazzy_51]

guessing thats James shields, but either way its a big old no from me... value wise you get hosed... Lince is a stud ace, quentin a 2nd rounder at best, and i believe JimEnez out produces Shields again this year hes flying under everyones radar somehow after his first full season produced 12 wins, 186 Ks and a sub 4 ERA... don't do that deal, your OF will hold up better then your pitching staff will without Lince and JimEnez... i know you have Johan, Lincecum and Bills, but don't sell short just because you have 3 studs...


help me out..
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=379036

[sreill]

I think I can talk him into taking Pelfry instead of Jiminez

[Mortician]

quenton doesn't really help you;. You have enough OF, not enough SP