M - Cab/ Longoria for Lincecum? WHIR (serious)

[bazzy_51]

ok just have to ask will this guy give you anything with Lince in return for either one? if not you do need SP help, you have enough bats in the barn there so if i were to do it i would do Longoria rather then Miggy as i see Miggy outproducing Longoria by a bit this year... either way its all around Atkins, if you think he can handle his weight starting at either 1B or 3B depending on if you trade either Miggy or Evan... i personally say NO to Miggy for Lince, but Longoria straight up really isn't that bad of deal straight up, and then looking at your shaky SP core that would be a huge boost... i really do like your Bats and think you could afford to get rid of one of your top bats to get a bare minimum a top 3 SP, i look at it this way, Lince in alot of drafts goes right before or right after Longoria so its not really THAT huge of a loss if you do Longoria/Lince, i would tho try to get somethin else back with Timmy... people need to look at not only the value IN the trade, but also the value that player BRINGS to the team... you would upgrade hugely on your SP... my vote is one for Longoria for Lincecum...

look at this:
Lincecum
Bedard
Kawakami
Cueto
Slowey/Anderson/Davies (then Escobar when he comes back

compared to:
Bedard
Kawakmi
Cueto
Anderson
Slowey

and then:
Martin
Miggy
Lopez
67/27/85/.272
Andrus

compared to:
Martin
Miggy
Lopez
89/21/99/.286

hmmm... not TOO big of a drop?

Help me out..?

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=379036

[SpecialFNK]

i think i would do Longoria for Lincecum, but not Cabrera.
Cabrera will have better numbers this season than Longoria. Longoria has started hot, but the way people rate him IMO he is overrated. he has a high K rate so i dont think he is going to have a great AVG. hes probually going to end up around where he was last season of .272 AVG. he allready has 5 HR which is good, but i think he is going to end up around 30+ HR compared to Cabrera who is going to be closer to 40.
Cabrera is a 1st round pick, but to me Longoria is a stretch even for a 2nd round pick. value wise i think Longoria for Lincecum is good.

help?
viewtopic.php?t=379049

[oldmanbean]

no way I'd do this... shop around for something else thats way too much for timmy

help? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=378423&start=10

Everyone keep trying to rip me off. Lincecum for M - cab was the fairest proposal i got. One guy kept trying to offer Billingsley for my Cabrera straight up.

I have no problem sitting on talented bats like Cabrera or Longoria, but I just wonder how long my Pitching staff can survive without an elite pitcher ........ BUMP, any other advice??

WHIR, Post Links!

Billingsley is quite a gem, I like that deal better ... better bats there to support him also.

thanks for help on mine!

[Tigers1223]

I would def keep M Cab