Is this trade worth Making Please Help

[augustbick]

I was asked to trade:
Ryan Howard
David Wright
Jimmy Rollins

For

Josh Beckett or Jake peavy
Jose B. Reyes
Scott Rolen

What do you think?

[irish158]

Are you kidding me. Not in a million years would I do that. I mean that does say Scott Rolen right?
Whoever proposed that to you is just trying to rip you off.

[MaudDib]

Umm...No. That would be a bad trade for you. You are giving up three studs so you should get three studs in return. Last I looked Rolen isn't a stud and I wouldn't put Beckett/Peavy in that boat either.