Maris09 wrote:I'll ask again....does anyone have experience playing in a league with BOTH Wins and QS's?
The concern that I would have with setting this up is that you are adding another quantity stat (encouraging more streaming). And there seems to a pretty good balance between ratios and quantity stats in the standard 5x5.
I play in a league that has both and they counter it with BAA. the more percentage categories you have; the harder it is to stream.
There are flaws in QS as well and his name is Rich Harden. There have been many times when I have seen Harden throw a gem, but because he strikes out 95% of the batters he is taken out at the end of 5 innings. This same thing happened to Greinke this week when he pitched well, struck out quite a few batters and then ended up sitting down after 5. He got a win, but not a QS. That is a joke. Of course you have a guy like Volquez who gave up 6 runs but got a win since Gallardo gave up 7.
You can't escape it, but over the course of the year it usually works itself out.