HUGE trade. Help!

[drew69]

points only league

Johan and Steven Drew for James Shields and Jose Reyes.
Which team gets the better deal?

R 2
H 2
2B 2
3B 4
HR 4
RBI 2
SB 3
BB 1
IP 2
W 8
L -4
CG 8
SHO 10
SV 10
ER -1
K 2
QS 10

[The Mighty Trow]

hmm... everyone seems to be a winner, but i give a slight edge to the shields/reyes side. shields is no santana, but he's good, and likely getting better. reyes is the key piece -- those triples and sbs will add up in a hurry

[MadDog36]

Shields is a QS machine and I like that in your league. Good deal get Reyes and Shields. Drew has a bit more upside for power but Reyes will hit a few of those and easily outproduce him in SB which is the difference.