Of course immma put Schafer first (
Kid's overrated huh (how does comparing to Johnny Damon (worst) and Sizemore (best) get you?
Fowler looks like more of a speed option, those homers were fluky. He has some power potential but its limited IMO.
Upton has the most upside here but he's kinda starting slowly in his career.
I'd go with Upton and Schafer. (due to lackest of competition).
If you have room consider adding Fowler (post roster).