Rank Schafer, Fowler,and Justin Upton WHIR

[TheGuru]

Please rank these 3

Schafer
Fowler
Justin Upton

[floyd1313]

schafer, upton, fowler for me

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

if its just for this year:

schafer, fowler, upton


please help
viewtopic.php?t=378888

[HOOTIE]

Upton
Fowler
Schafer overrated

[MadDog36]

Of course immma put Schafer first ( ).

Kid's overrated huh (how does comparing to Johnny Damon (worst) and Sizemore (best) get you?

Fowler looks like more of a speed option, those homers were fluky. He has some power potential but its limited IMO.

Upton has the most upside here but he's kinda starting slowly in his career.

I'd go with Upton and Schafer. (due to lackest of competition).

If you have room consider adding Fowler (post roster).

[mak1277]

Kid's overrated huh (how does comparing to Johnny Damon (worst) and Sizemore (best) get you?

Johnny Damon's first full year he hit .271/.313/.368 with 61 runs and 50 RBIs. I think that's probably a fair approximation of what you'll get out of Schaefer this year. He's going to be good, but he's currently overrated in terms of how well he will perform for this year alone.

Upton last year hit .250/.353/.463. Even if he just matches that this year he'll be more valuable than Schaefer. Big caveat on whether he gets playing time though.

[dagactor]

Fowler, Schafer, Upton

Fowler will end up full time in a month, I bet.