do u like you Youk and Doumit for Holiday

[petert]

currently have holiday but am thinking of trading him for Doumit and Youkilis???

Napoli, Mike C ANA
Varitek, Jason C BOS
Davis, Chris 3B TEX
Kinsler, Ian 2B TEX
Zimmerman, Ryan 3B WAS
Furcal, Rafael SS LA
Escobar, Yunel SS ATL
Sandoval, Pablo 1B SF
Bay, Jason LF BOS
Choo, Shin-Soo RF CLE
Holliday, Matt LF OAK
Pence, Hunter RF HOU
Rios, Alex RF TOR
Spilborghs, Ryan RF COL

[marsrover21]

I don't think you'll get those two guys, but yeah, do it in a minute if you can.

[dagactor]

Yes, Doumit is waaaay better than Varitek and will play more than Napoli...and you don't seem to have a 1B.

[petert]

i have C. Davis at 1st base and i have Weiters on my bench.......
I picked Holiday in the first round and had him last year. i like him alot but Youk maybe just as good. Plus i get Doumit now since Variteck is so bad.

thanks so much for everyones input. I am so on the fence with this one and have always hated trading this early.

currently in first place fyi and i won it last year. twelve teams 5x5

[irish158]

Youk is a nice player, but he is not Holliday. Holliday will steal you a decent number of bases and still should be around .300 with the same power numbers if not better. But, if you can pull the trade off, I'd to it in a second.

[petert]

the deal is 100% in the table....anybody else? anybody think not to do it?