Gordon vs Atkins
Gordon is struggling I think about jumping out of his bandwagon ( for this year). Atkins is struggling too... but is more versatile since he can play 1B and 3B. He is more proven so I give the edge to Atkins.
Magglio vs Damon
Magglio is a better hitter for sure, he got more power , produce a lot of RBIs and is batting is consistent. And Damon provides me some speed to. But I give the edge to Magglio
Wright vs Cabrera
I love Miguel but wright is give me the SB that Miguel is not. But Miguel will hit more long balls. It's a wash IMO.
But I have Bobby Abreu who fill that RF (Ordonez's) spot and leave util spot to another hitter. I have a good bench (Hank Balock, Yadier Molina, Dexter Fowler,Aaron Hill, Lastings Milledge
Based on team needs I think it makes sense.