TRADE: Hamilton for Lee/Ethier

[boyogold]

I give Hamilton, he gives Lee/Ethier.

12 Team H2H (pts based)
Single = 1
Double = 2
Triple = 3
Home Run = 4
Run = 1
RBI = 1
Walk = 1
Stolen Base = 2
Caught Stealing = -1

My roster
Mike Napoli (C,Util , LAA)
Miguel Cabrera (1B,3B,Util , DET)
Dustin Pedroia (2B,Util , BOS)
Adrian Beltre (3B,Util , SEA)
Troy Tulowitzki (SS,Util , COL)
Shane Victorino (OF,Util , PHI)
Torii Hunter (OF,Util , LAA)
Josh Hamilton (OF,Util , TEX)
David Ortiz (1B,Util , BOS)

Philadelphia Phillies (P , PHI)

Billy Butler (1B,Util , KC)
Matt Weiters (C,Util , ARI)
Edgar Renteria (SS,Util , SF)
Ryan Spilborghs (OF, Util, COL)
Hideki Matsui (OF,Util , NYY)

Milwaukee Brewers (P, MIL)




His Roster:
Victor Martinez (C,1B,Util , CLE)
Mark Teixeira (1B,Util , NYY)
Dan Uggla (2B,Util , FLA)
Alex Gordon (3B,Util , KC)
Rafael Furcal (SS,Util , LAD)
Matt Holliday (OF,Util , OAK)
Magglio Ordonez (OF,Util , DET)
Ryan Church (OF,Util , NYM)
Andre Ethier (OF,Util , LAD)

Los Angeles Angels (P , LAA)

Bench
Derrek Lee (1B,Util , CHC)
Orlando Cabrera (SS,Util , OAK)
Chris Young (OF,Util , ARI)
Edwin Encarnacion (3B,Util , CIN)
Bengie Molina (C,Util , SF)
Mike Fontenot (2B,Util , CHC)


This guy really wants Hamilton as this is the third offer he's given me for him. Right now I'm kind of reticent to give him up. If you don't like this trade, do you have a counteroffer that I could give him for Hamilton that would be better for me?

Thanks in advance...

[Big League Chew]

I don't really like this deal for you. I tend to like upgrading to one player instead of getting 2 for 1. If I were you, I would go after the big Tex. If he's that crazy about Hamilton then make him pay for it. If I were you I would offer Hamilton and Beltre (or some other chump) for the big Tex. Then you can move Miggy to 3B. This is what I would do. Try to get Teixeira before he starts lighting it up.

[frogfan]

I'd hold on to Hamilton. Unless he's giving up Texeiria or Holliday in the deal I am not interested, and even then, I'd probably keep Hamilton.

Hamilton and Beltre or Matsui for Tex and Ethier might be interesting -- could move Cabrera to 3b...not sure if he'd go for it, but could be good for you.

[Tommy John]

If this is Carlos Lee, I think I would pull the trigger. What is going to be the difference between Hamilton and Lee? Plus you get Ethier to boot

[boyogold]

For Carlos Lee v Hamilton...I guess not too much. But unfortunately we're talking about Derrek Lee.

[dagactor]

Major downgrade. If this dude is so high on Hammy? See if he'll do something stupid like Tex/Holliday for Hammy/Beltre. Or even Tex/Ethier.

Help me?
viewtopic.php?t=378728

[crowcrow]

For Derrek Lee & Either, I would not drop Hamilton. Unless it is Carlos Lee.