Aaron Hill vs Christian Guzman WHIR 100%

[Hit Factory]

Hey, I am debating whether or not to drop Aaron Hill and pickup Christian Guzman. I have Hill at the middle infielder position and I like him, however Guzman is a tremendous average hitter and it's a tough call, (I could drop my current SS, Khalil Greene and Guzman could take his place and I could keep Hill at MI.) what do you guys think?
WHIR as always!

[The Mighty Trow]

i like hill and greene over guzman. guzman has 2.3 (or so ) seasons where his average was above .274, so i'd expect a lot of regression there. he doesn't really offer anything else of value over hill and greene.

[Tommy John]

I am on the other end of the spectrum, I think Guzman will continue to hit for a high average, PECOTA loves the guy. I like Hill as well, wish I had him, he had the potential to be just outside the top 5 2B before the injury. It does not seem to affect him now so I think he could very well continue his progression. Greene is what he is, a power SS who may top out at .260, highly unlikely. He benefits from the lineup he is in based on his position within the lineup, if he continues to hit in the middle of the order he will see some good pitches to hit. For avg. purposes though, I think Guzman would be a good choice, and I think Hill will be a very good 2B.

viewtopic.php?t=378724