Need BIG TIME HELP Which Bat?.. WHIR!!!!!!!!!!!

[TheBambino]

Im thinking of dropping H.Matsui (should I even drop him)? for 1 of these guys
- Span
- Konerko
- A Hill
- Thome
- Giambi
- D Young
- Fowler
- K Johnson
- Theriot
- Morgan
- Fukudome
- O Hudson
- Scutaro
- Schafer

Here is my team
10 Team Keeper Mixed Vanilla 5x5 League
C - R Doumit
1B - J Morneau
2B - B Roberts
SS - D Jeter
3B - A Ramirez
OF - G Sizemore
OF - H Pence
OF - A Dunn
Util - J Bruce
Util - H Matsui
Bn - Adam Jones

SP - D Haren
SP - J Lackey
SP - D Matsuzaka
SP - J Johnson
RP - J Nathan
RP - BJ Ryan
RP - M Lindstrom
BN - C Carpenter
BN - M Scherzer
BN - S Downs

[dagactor]

Hill, Theriot, and Fowler to stash on the bench would be my choices. You can't afford Giambi/Thome avg killing if you already have Dunn on board. You can probably move Carpenter to the DL soon too :-(

[TheBambino]

Id have to drop Matsui for only 1 of these guys..... which one? and are they all better than Matsui?

[espnsportsfan]

i would add konerko and start him at util...imo carp is not headed for the DL, its a rib injury

[TheBambino]

isnt konerko going to kill my avg with Dunn in it?... A good positional player to back me up at 2b, ss and 3b would be good to add too... HELLLP! haha

[Seisto]

I like Kelly Johnson, think he's going to be pretty steady all year, showing some decent power and projects much better than Matsui. Not sure if you buy into it, but PECOTA has Johnson at .287/90/17/75 and 10+ SB. Looks like his first week is justifying that.

Aside from that, Fowler seems to be nailing down a starting job and Denard Span and Jordan Schafer appear to have already done so. Obviously Orlando Hudson is off to a killer start, but that has to plateau. I'd forget about Thome and Giambi like others have said and if it's average you're going for, I hate to even suggest it but someone finally picked up Fukudome in a league of mine this afternoon and I think he might be on to something.

Eeek, hope I didn't put you in a deeper hole there -- good luck.


http://tinyurl.com/c4hhpa

[HOOTIE]

Span and Konerko for Matsui and Downs

[TheBambino]

what do you guys think>? Im thinking of dropping Matsui and moving Lackey to DL to free up 2 spots.... then I grab?...

- K Johnson
- Hill
- Theriot
- Konerko
- Span
- Fowler

Does any of this work for my team?

10 Team Keeper Mixed Vanilla 5x5 League
C - R Doumit
1B - J Morneau
2B - B Roberts
SS - D Jeter
3B - A Ramirez
OF - G Sizemore
OF - H Pence
OF - A Dunn
Util - J Bruce
Util - H Matsui
Bn - Adam Jones

SP - D Haren
SP - J Lackey
SP - D Matsuzaka
SP - J Johnson
RP - J Nathan
RP - BJ Ryan
RP - M Lindstrom
BN - C Carpenter
BN - M Scherzer
BN - S Downs

[HOOTIE]

Span is a easy choice. I might add Fowler if you have a chance to keep him?

[TheBambino]

I only have 6 keepers.... im pretty sure i have them already... This is my list as of today.. might change by the end of the year.
Sizemore
Morneau
Pence
Nathan
Haren
J Johnson


So I added K Johnson today to backfill for Roberts and add a little in the Util slot when hes hot. Should I drop Matsui for Span or Theriot (who would backup jeter?0