Trade Big Josh for "Big-Boned" CC?

[jmcampbe11]

10 team roto keeper league (we carry over 3 players each season). With that in mind, should I make this trade? Keep in mind Hamilton would be one of my keepers.

GIVE - Hamilton/Gallardo/Reynolds
GET - Sabathia/M.Ordonez/A.Gordon

C-Martin 1b-A.Gonzalez 2b-Phillips ss-O.Cabrera 3b-Longoria CI-Reynolds MI-Alx.Ramirez OF-Hamilton, Sizemore, V.Wells, Dye, Ad. Jones Util-Nady
SP-Gallardo, Greinke, Nolasco, Lilly, R.Johnson, *Smoltz
RP-Broxton, Qualls, Morrow, Percival, Aredondo, Ray

[jmcampbe11]

Any thoughts fellas?

PS) Pick up Ray if you have an open roster spot. I'm watching the Os/Rangers game and Sherrill is getting rocked again.

[billycent]

No, stay put, ur pretty solid and Hamilton is a great keeper. C.C. scares me. Thnx for the help on mine.

[Xander756]

I agree. I was never a big fan of C.C. so I would probably keep your current lineup, it looks pretty good. I like Gallardo a lot.

[reverend]

Don't do it. Guys tend to fade in New York these days...too much pressure and CC is already showing it. I had a chance to draft him and took Halladay instead because the lack of pressure to be a stud.

[cdawg4343]

Thanks for helping me out. If you get a chance check mine again b/c of new developments.
viewtopic.php?t=378608

I would stay put. Hamilton is a great keeper for next year.

[coma]

Don't do it. You'd be getting a great pitcher in CC, but he is nowhere near as valuable as Hamilton. Especially in a keeper.

Thanks for the help!

[Singles]

I think I would do this deal. You could really use an ace on your staff and the addition of CC will really make it a solid staff. I think you can afford to lose Hamilton in that lineup and still have three excellent keepers with Longoria, Sizemore and either Jones or Ramirez.

[jmcampbe11]

Keep them coming folks. Thanks again for all the help.

[ezgoin92]

Thanks for the help on mine.

I'd stay put. Like others - I like Hamilton and I'm afraid of what this year will bring for C.C.