Am I giving too much for Ichiro? ALL HELP RETURNED

[kaiser]

Leave a link for all help returned. Cafe honor.

10 team keeper h2h

Just offered to me:

I give Yovanni Gallardo and Nelson Cruz

I get Ichiro, Coco Crisp, Mike Jacobs.

I still believe in Ichiro, but is giving Cruz and Gallardo too much? My other SP are Billingsly, Lilly, Javier Vasquez and John Danks.

My other OF are Soriano, Braun, Kemp and Mike Cameron, with Elijah Dukes and Jeff Francouer on the bench.

I'm leaning toward yes. Thoughts?

[kaiser]

Help! I'm afraid this offer goes away if I wait much longer.

[Rance Mulliniks]

IMHO too much. I love Ichi's avg, but his SB will be down this year. I like Gallardo's upside and am high on Cruz (though you can get a lot of value for him right now). The trade isn't terrible, but I don't like Crisp or Jacobs and think you could do better.

Good luck.

[kaiser]

Thanks, Rance. Anyone else?

[kidsilk]

I think you are giving up too much here. I am really high on Gallardo and Cruz this year and think you could get more for their combo than IChiro and company. I would stay put or counter for more value.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=378522