Trade involving Tex and Utley!! WHIRWHIRWHIR

[Barnes]

I was offered his Mark Texiera and BJ Ryan for my Chase Utley....should i make this trade? I am strong at 1st with Fielder, but weak in OF so maybe i should go after one of his rather than tex??

It is a 5x5 keeper h2h 12 team league.

Rosters:

Mine

C- Brian McCann
1b - Prince Fielder
2b- Chase Utley
3b- Aubrey Huff
SS- JJ Hardy
OF - Josh Hamilton,
OF - Xavier Nady,
OF - Nelso Cruz,
OF - Jordan Schafer
OF - Ryan Spilbourghs
UTL- Matt LaPorta
UTL - Travis Hafner
UTL - Dan Murphy
BENCH - Carlos Gomez, Aaron Hill, Cody Ross, Skip Schumaker,
SP - CC Sabathia, Francisco Liriano, Zach Grienke, Joe Saunders, Mike Pelfrey, Chris Carpenter, Anothy Reyes
RP - Jason Motte, Grant Balfour, Matt Lindstrom


HIS[b][/b]

C -John Baker
1B- Mark Teixeira
2B Rickie Weeks
(3B Miguel Cabrera
SS Orlando Cabrera
OF Felipe López, Matt Holliday, Magglio Ordonez, BJ Upton, Coco Crisp
Util Jim Thome
Util Yunel Escobar
Util Jorge Cantú
BN Clint Barmes
BN Carlos Beltrán
BN Adam LaRoche
DL Joe Mauer


SP A.J. Burnett, Justin Verlander, Ian Snell, matt cain, John Smoltz, Kelvim Escobar
RP Jonathan Pabelbon, Mariano Rivera, Brad Lidge. Kevin Gregg, BJ Ryan, Jonathon Broxton

[TheGuru]

I wouldn't touch Ryan. I wouldn't do the trade because you would be crippled at 2B. It's easier to find someone to fill in at util then it is second

[buckfoston07]

I agree, maybe downgrade to Holliday and upgrade the closer? But I think you should definitely go for an outfielder instead.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=378498

[The Mighty Trow]

you don't need tex at all. an outfielder, yes, but he doesn't have any of comparable value. utley is at a primo position, i'd look to keep him at all costs. someone like beltran or upton would be nice, but i can't find the right synergies based on those rosters.

good luck

plez help:
viewtopic.php?t=378478

[Barnes]

So maybe holliday and Broxton for Utley? but like someone said id be finished at 2b

[shmolex]

I wouldn't do either trade for utley. You dont need tex and I think you can get more then holliday. I wouldn't actually trade utley at all if i was in your position.

viewtopic.php?t=378495

[Barnes]

what about a trade to this tune:..

MY aaron hill, Jordan Schafer, Zach Greinke

for

HIS Jonathan Broxton, Matt Holliday

Do you think he'd go for this, is it a sufficient offfer??

thanks in advance

[philaphan]

I would not trade utley. As for the latest offer I don't think your offer would be enough to get Holiday & Broxton.

I would have to see his roster inorder to see what needs has. Than maybe you could offer something that would fill his voids and land you Holiday

Please help me!
viewtopic.php?t=378550

[Barnes]

I would not trade utley. As for the latest offer I don't think your offer would be enough to get Holiday & Broxton.

I would have to see his roster inorder to see what needs has. Than maybe you could offer something that would fill his voids and land you Holiday

Please help me!
viewtopic.php?t=378550

his roster is above in the first msg of the thread!

[Barnes]

Bump..........Sorry for hte bump, and thanks!