manny/peavy/qualls/francisco for CC/Lincecum/lidge WHIR

[fierro33]

Huge trade offer

i receive :

Sabathia
Lincecum
Lidge

i give:

Manny
Peavy
qualls
francisco


10 team h2h 5x5 non keeper

C Ramon hernandez
1b Carlos pena
2b bonifacio
3b alex Rodriguez DL
ss jose reyes
OF Grady Sizemore
OF Manny Ramirez
OF Bobby Abreu
Util David wright
bench
Ibanez
vernon wells
matt weiters


Pitching

Jake Peavy
Scott Baker
kevin Slowey
Randy johnson
kawakami
escobar
marra




nathan
soria
bj ryan
marmol
morrow
capps
francisco
qualls
hanrahan

[dooho]

personally in a H2H i prefer relievers over starters in a 5x5, with only relievers you realistically will win 3 out of 5 pitching categories every week (saves, era, whip). so while i like lidge, the two you have are fine. you are deep at closer, why not target lincecum by offering nathan and and a starter like baker or escobar, or you could offer nathan and another closer - or one of your bench hitters. you have some depth, make a solid 2 for 1 offer that can bring you a stud.

would you mind seeing mine?

viewtopic.php?t=378387

[RenPastana]

I'd stay put...Hitters, especially the ones like Manny that are super consistent, are way more valuable in H2H...Plus you can always find spot starters off the wire!

thanks for the help with mine

[fierro33]

anyone else?

[billycent]

U need the help at SP but if u have to give up Man Ram to do it I gots to say the nay no. Try to deal somebody else straight up or a 2 for 1 for another starter instead of all of that. Qualls and Francisco will do u just fine and no need to part ways w/Peavy. Here's mine.

viewtopic.php?t=378406