Owner trading for a (1b/3b) guy

[the izzy]

10 team, re-draft, H2H
Here's the offer:

I get: A. Huff and J. Damon
I give: M. Cabrera (1B/3B).

Obviously, I'm not going to do that. I actually have zero interest in trading Cabrera at all. But I feel that I should counter.

I'm thinking:

I give: Chris Davis + Abreu
I get: Ichiro

or maybe try to go for a SP, throwing in 1 of my 5 closers. Nolasco or Harden or Shields would be nice additions

IDK, suggestions?

My team:
C: Sandoval
1B: A. Gonzalez
2B: C. Utley
3B: M. Cabrera (1B/3B)
SS: S. Drew
OF: M. Ramirez
OF: Ludwick
OF: N. Cruz
UTIL: D. Ortiz
BN: B. Abreu, C. Davis (1B/3B), M. Weiters (C - NA)
DL: Alex Rodriquez (3B)

SP: Harang, Gallardo, Bedard, Vazquez, Felix, M. Scherzer
RP: M. Gonzalez, Qualls, Bell, Francisco, B. Morrow

His Team:
C: Victor Martinez
1B: Youkilis
2B: I. Stewart
3B: A. Huff
SS: J. Reyes
OF: J. Damon
OF: J. Ellsbury
OF: C. Quentin
UTIL: Lind
BN: Uggla, Wells, Burrell, Posada
DL: Ichiro

SP: Shields, Zambrano, Nolasco, Joe Saunders, Buehrle, Myers, Harden
RP: Broxton, Wheeler, Hoffman (DL)