RJohnson/Spilborghs for Dye ? ..WHIR

[SpecialFNK]

i give- Randy Johnson, Ryan Spilborghs
i get- Jermaine Dye

hows this deal?
the other guy has told me he is looking for pitching. i told him last week i could offer either Randy Johnson or Chris Young. with Young pitching well and Johnson get lit up today im going to choose to try and ship out Johnson.
i have other pitching so losing Johnson is nothing. i like Dye power numbers and he is better than Spilborghs.
i dont know if i can get other players involved, you can look at the teams and give me advice.

MY ROSTER
CA- B McCann
1B- L Berkman
2B- K Johnson
3B- K Kouzmanoff
SS- D Jeter
CI- D Lee
MI- F Lopez
OF- G Sizemore
OF- M Kemp
OF- C Young
OF- Ad Jones
UT- P Konerko
UT- F Lewis
BN- C Dickerson
BN- E Andrus
BN- B Inge
BN-K Morales

SP- D Haren
SP- J Shields
RP- J Nathan
RP- C Villanueva
P- C Young
P- J Vazquez
P- R Johnson
P- W Rodriguez
BN- H Kuroda
BN- C Ray
DL- T Hoffman
DL- J Zumaya

HIS ROSTER
CA- I Rodriguez
1B- J Morneau
2B- O Hudson
3B- C Jones
SS- M Tejada
CI- E Encarnacion
MI- C Barmers
OF- A Soriano
OF- J Hamilton
OF- J Dye
OF- V Guerrero
UT- N McLouth
UT- M Napoli
BN- K Griffey
BN- F Sanchez
BN- K Suzuki

SP- R Nolasco
SP- J Chamberlain
RP- J Papelbon
RP- B Ziegler
P- K Gregg
P- T Saito
P- H Okajima
P- J Putz
BN- C Kershaw
BN- T Lilly
BN- F Morales
DL- E Santana
DL- J Duchscherer

(note- i have a proposal out, Grady Sizemore/Brandon Inge for David Wright)

leave a link, WHIR.

[Surfs up]

Man thats a tough call. I like Spilborghs alot in Colorado. But Dye is also in a hitter friendly park. I think I keep Dye. You know hes going to get 30 plus hrs. Thats a given Johnson could go on the DL tomorrow and Spil is unproven. Think I pass.

[jmcampbe11]

I'd do it. Dye is an upgrade over Lewis and your pitching staff is deep enough to weather losing the Big Unit.

Can you return the favor on my Staff Ace post?

[somervillesoxfan]

do it your pitching will be fine without the unit. Dye will have a huge year this year.

help
viewtopic.php?t=377969

[RenPastana]

Do it! You can find hitters like Spilly on the WW but no Dye's! Simple as that! Randy is not looking so good anymore and I own him!
:( .. anyway...My say is GO!

help plz
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=378342

[Rance Mulliniks]

I'd do this for sure. Dye is an underrated offensive powerhouse in fantasy. RJs on a terrible team, looked pretty bad today and is replaceable.

Good luck!