I would have to agree that a Pujols for Sheffield/Anderson/Loaiza trade is unfair. Even without Loaiza. While i do not think that Sheffield is the player that Pujols is I think that Garrett Anderson is VASTLY underrated. The two of them for one player is just not fair- no matter who it is. Look at it like this- in our draft, Sheffield will go for about $32, Anderson will go for about $28, and Loaiza will probably go for about $15. Pujols will go for about $45.
That is $75 worth of draft day talent for $45. Granted you are getting the best player in the game, but it is still unfair in my opinion. You can talk about the "Risk" factors with Sheffield but it goes both ways. In order for Pujols to do what he did last year, Renteria has to do what he did last year, Edmonds has to stay healthy for a whole year, Sanders has to do what he did last year, and they have Marlon Anderson leading off. I would not bet against Pujols, but I gaurantee that at least one of those things does not happen!!