Offering Holliday/Liriano for Hamilton?!?!?! WHIR

[Joshiroth]

It's an 8-team Points League. I'm trying to get rid of Holliday and Liriano and bring in Hamilton. I just want some advice about whether this would be too much to give up or if it sounds good. Keep in mind that I have just gone through with another trade that has landed me Soriano and Cano for Pedroia. So is this trade goes through this is my roster:

C Matt Wieters
(Bal - C) NA
1B Mark Teixeira
(NYY - 1B)
2B Robinson Cano
(NYY - 2B)
3B David Wright
(NYM - 3B)
SS Derek Jeter
(NYY - SS)
OF Josh Hamilton
(Tex - OF)
OF Alfonso Soriano
(Cubs - OF)
OF Jermaine Dye
(CWS - OF)
Util Adrián González
(SD - 1B)
SP Kevin Slowey
(Min - SP)
SP Tim Lincecum
(SF - SP)
SP Aaron Harang
(Cin - SP)
RP Mariano Rivera
(NYY - RP)
RP Brad Lidge
(Phi - RP)
BN Erik Bedard
(Sea - SP)
BN Zack Greinke
(KC - SP)
BN Ryan Ludwick
(Stl - OF)
BN Ubaldo Jiménez
(Col - SP)
BN Chris Carpenter
(StL - SP)

[scorched03]

a) badly formatted posts dont get read, and that is a horribly formatted post
b) i dont think that's enough to get him though. i think ur team is fine already

[silverZ]

In a deep league that might be enough to get him, but with only 8 teams their must be a bunch of studs on the wire so people are less willing to trade their big studs. Offer it anyway and maybe you'll get lucky and end up with hamilton and a random stud sp off the wire.

[MadDog36]

That is enough to get him. But your pressing panic too soon.

What FAs are out there?

[coma]

I'm not too worried about Holliday, but I say pull the trigger. Hammy is an absolute MONSTER.

[Trebor]

i think u are offering enough, maybe too much. i like Hammy a lot, but kinda think u may be paying too much. i like Liriano a lot. id rather sell Harang or Bedard, but not sure if they would be enough (altho they both just had AMAZING sunday starts, so maybe strike while iron is hot?)

i mean every1 is low-balling on Holliday since he moved away from Coors, but his road avg last year was still .308 (which is better than Hammys avg last year)


hit back please

viewtopic.php?t=378187