BJ Upton coming of the DL, who to drop? WHIR!!

[mayfijr]

C - Ryan Doumit
1st - Ryan Howard
2nd - Ian Kinsler
3rd - David Wright
SS - Stephen Drew
2nd/SS - Jose Lopez
1st/3rd - Alex Gordon
OF - Magglio Ordonez
OF - Jason Bay
OF - Carlos Quentin
OF - Raul Ibanez
OF - Jordan Schafer
U - Melvin Mora
U - Mark Reynolds
SP - Billingsley, Lowe, Verlander, Garza, Kershaw, Wang, Danks,
RP - Capps, M. Gonzalez, Gregg
Bench - Justin Upton, Ubaldo Jimenez, Andy Sonnanstine

B.J. Upton is coming off of the DL tomorrow. Who should I drop? I'm thinking Sonnanstine.

[somervillesoxfan]

definitely drop Sonnsatine,

help
viewtopic.php?t=377969

[HipHipJorge]

I personally like having more P than hitters. So if your like that I would drop Schafer. I mean is he gonna play with BJ on your team? But if you want to keep the bats than Sonnas is good

[mayfijr]

I could play Schafer at Utility when Upton comes back. I guess that brings up the question would you rather have Schafer, Mark Reynolds, or Justin Upton. I read today that Justin may be headed to Triple-A soon if he doesn't start hitting.

[HipHipJorge]

I am a fan boy of J Up. So do not make me pick. If you really think Schafer will produce then keep him. Drop Sonnas.

I personally think Schaf will not outproduce your current Utils. I am assumin reynolds is there for power.

On another note; if you are HIGH on schafer..you might think about flippin one other OF for another pitcher.

[MadDog36]

Sonnanstine can be replaced easily.

You can use your new found OF depth to acquire something somewhere else.

[Trebor]

drop Sonna

or if u like carrying extra pitchers rather than extra bats, then drop Schaffer (i think he topped out at like 10-15 HRs/yr in minors, so doubt the homers will continue) or J.Upton (seems he needs some AAA time to hone his talent)

me, i drop Sonna

fellow BJ owner in same predicament, hit back please

viewtopic.php?t=378187

[Johnny Tuttle]

Sonnanstine is a perfectly fine fantasy pitcher, but I think you could replace him very easily.

In my annual group of redraft owners, there's a guy who treats our leagues like keepers. He drafts and overdrafts for Hughes, Maybin, Snider, and a whole host of prospects/youngsters every year, and while he often gets the breakouts (he had had Braun from day 1 of that season), he gets a lot of variable production, too, and rarely wins. I'd look for that guy in your league to sell Schafer high. If you get a price like he's going to good all year, you've increased your value and taken away your risk.