longoria and soriano trade...WHIR

[decatur squares]

Hello,

I want to see who you think would get the better of this trade.

Longoria, Granderson, Lester for Soriano, Zimmerman, Alexi Ram., Joba Cham.

[coma]

In a vacuum give me side one. Longoria has been lights out and I like the other two. I definitely don't believe in Zimmerman and Ramirez hasn't looked too good.

Help?
viewtopic.php?t=378079

[fleurent21]

This trade, by itself, is pretty even. Because of the additional player side 2 gets I'd say it's a wash. I think Joba/Lester is even. Moving to offense Longoria/Granderson are better than any combination of 2 of the other 3, but the addition of another player evens it up.
It's very dependant on the 2 rosters to see who would fair better on this trade though.

[url][http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=378050/url]

[HipHipJorge]

Lester >>> Joba

Longoria has less injury risk than Soriano (but both unconcious right now)

Zimmer; you have no idea what you getting v. Granderson = Win for granderson

Alexi makes it closer. But remember you're also getting an open bench spot (if youre team 1)