Should i do this trade??

[Jond4414]

I give Halladay, Wood and Kendrick
I get BJ Upton, Jonathan Papelbon and Randy Johnson

I know its early but my hitting is really struggling and i was planning on unloading one of my pitchers for a good hitter anyways cause I have a pitching surplus. relief pitching is a huge concern for me and getting papelbon will def ease my concerns. What do you guys think? This is not a keeper.

Heres my team

C- Victor Martinez
1B- Lance Berkman
2B- Robinson Cano
3B- Chris Davis
SS- Stephen Drew
OF- Carl Crawford
OF- Nick Markakis
OF- Jay Bruce
Util- Chone Figgins
Util- David Ortiz
Util- Justin Upton
Util- Howie Kendrick
Util- Adrien Beltre
DL- Arod

SP- Johan Santana
SP-Roy Halladay
SP-Francisco Liriano
SP- Zach Greinke
SP- Javier Vazquez
RP-Kerry Wood
RP- Brandon Morrow

Its a head to head league with the following categories...R,H,HR,RBI,SB,FPCT,AVG,OBP,OPS, W,L,CG,SV,ERA,WHIP,K/BB,K/9,QS

[dave knight]

That's a very good deal to get an elite hitter and the 2nd best closer in the game.

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

i think this deal is good for you. I hate giving up Halladay this early, but i think you should pull the trigger.

I might try to throw Liriano instead of Halladay, and maybe get a little be less of a closer than papelbon.


please help
viewtopic.php?t=377853

[Jond4414]

i actually tried to give him liriano and but hes all about halladay especially after his great performance today.

[Jond4414]

anyone else?

[jmcampbe11]

I'd do it. You'd still have an ace in Santana, to anchor your staff, and I think you're getting solid value in return.

Can you return the favor on my Reynolds post plz?