Trade: E. Santana for Slowey?

[lexsportiva]

I've been offered Ervin Santana for Kevin Slowey.

My current rotation is:

P Kevin Slowey, Min SP
P Ted Lilly, ChC SP
P Andy Sonnanstine, TB SP
P Dan Haren, Ari SP
P Andy Pettitte, NYY SP
P Fernando Rodney, Det RP
P Brian Fuentes, LAA RP
P Johnny Cueto, Det SP
P Carlos Villanueva, Mil RP
P Hiroki Kuroda, LAD SP (DL15)

Any thoughts on whether this is a good offer?

[Diamond Miners]

With the question marks around Ervin, and the fact that there is no way I see him producing the same as last years numbers, I'd stick with Slowey. Especially if WHIP is a category in your league.

[Rance Mulliniks]

I'd actually take Ervin's upside over Slowey - I think there would be a lot of SPs on the WW that can replicate Slowey's output. However, with Kuroda already on the DL, can you afford to stash Santana?