Help quick before this guy takes down trades WHIR

[Turbostasis25]

I tried something different, snagging 6 pitchers in a row after first picking hanley, now my trade box is full of some pretty good offers since I have a stranglehold on pitching, I'm debating on 2 ones and I need your guys' help, WHIR

12 team 5x5 h2h

Johan
Sabathia
Peavy
Haren
Galarraga
Sonnanstine (spot starter)

Rivera
Nathan
Brandon Lyon

C Posada
1B Votta
2B Kendrick
SS Hanley Ramirez
3B Zimmerman/Beltre
OF Dye / Chris Young
OF Jay Bruce /Taveras
OF Ethier / Justin Upton
Util Guillen

DL Glaus
DL Smoltz



The trades are Ian Kinsler straight up for Peavy, or Kinsler and Jair Jurrjens for Sabathia, which should I do?

[drunkmonkey]

Kinsler for Peavy. Sabathia will out-perform in the long run, and you can pick up a Jurrjens-like pitcher later. Take this trade immediately.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=377597