Which deal do you like better

[Lauren Matthew]

I have 4 closers. The only ones that I'm willing to move are Mariano Rivera and Troy Percival.

Which would you pull the trigger on:

Mariano Rivera for Andruw Jones (no luck on getting Manny Ramirez)

or

Troy Percival for Ryan Klesko

Please just comment on the 2 options. I know there are better options but no one is biting. I need power and will any of these 2 be good enough.

[Bobble Head]

I don't like either deal. Hold out for a better OF.

[jaroche24]

You should continue to try for better offers than those but if you have to decide between the two I'd take the first offer. Jones is consistent and is entering his prime. Rivera is aging and has been having injury problems of late.

Percival may have injury problems but Klesko is not enough if you are trying to trade him.

[Apex]

You should continue to try for better offers than those but if you have to decide between the two I'd take the first offer. Jones is consistent and is entering his prime. Rivera is aging and has been having injury problems of late.

Percival may have injury problems but Klesko is not enough if you are trying to trade him.

Agree all around.