Keeper Trade Help

[water boy]

I got offered this trade today.

14 team h2h we keep 12players

i give Monerau and Swisher for Manny Ramirez and Garrett Atkins

my roster

batting

H/AB R HR RBI SB AVG


C Ramón Hernández
1B Justin Morneau
2B Plácido Polanco
3B Melvin Mora
SS Derek Jeter
OF Vladimir Guerrero
OF Bobby Abreu
OF José Guillén
Util Carlos Guillén
Util Hank Blalock
BN Michael Bourn
BN Joe Mauer
BN Nick Swisher
BN David DeJesús
Pitching
IP W SV K ERA WHIP

SP Daisuke Matsuzaka
SP Edinson Vólquez
SP Roy Halladay
SP Anibal Sánchez
RP Bobby Jenks
RP J.J. Putz
RP Brian Wilson
P Armando Galarraga
P James McDonald
BN Kelvim Escobar
BN Mark Buehurle
DL Jeremy Bonderman
DL Joel Zumaya

[taw856]

It's kind of a wash, but I think I'd take that.

I like Morneau over Atkins by about as much as I like Manny over Swisher, but I'll take the Atkins side for the increased flexibility of Atkins being 1b/3b in a lot of leagues.

Mine: viewtopic.php?t=377318

[water boy]

i was thinking the same thing, anyone else

thanks,

[water boy]

anyone else think i should do this trade,

[water boy]

anyone?

[espnsportsfan]

i would take the trade, swisher may lose some at bats because of the crowd in the NY outfield

[water boy]

anyone have any imput before i pull the trigger

thanks