HUGE TRADE, PLEASE HELP...WHIR 100%

[Hit Factory]

I am thinking about proposing a pretty big trade, here it is: I trade Billingsley/Dye/Khalil Greene or Juan Pierre for Beckett/Rios/Furcal. I know the Greene or Pierre for Furcal is a reach, what do you guys think?

[Neboguy]

This trade seems a bit better. It's fairly close with you coming out better at the SS position. I would do it.

[SumG]

I would be stunned if this trade was accepted. The players you're giving up aren't nearly worth what you're receiving.

Beckett>Bills (close)
Rios>Dye (not close)
Furcal>Greene/Pierre (very not close)

[dave knight]

Too greedy, in my view from here.

[Rance Mulliniks]

Your reaching on this one. Good for you if it gets accepted, but I don't see why he'd accept (since he would be downgrading all positions).

[coma]

I don't think there is a chance he accepts it. You will have to throw out Greene/Pierre and put in a decent player. Unfortunately you might also need a slight upgrade over Dye in the trade too.

Help?
viewtopic.php?t=377215