possible Peavy trade

[KriSpYY162]

I was thinking of trying a trade with a guy who is interested in Peavy...

Peavy/Doumit/J.Lopez for R.Martin/Garza/Pedroia
Is that really bad ?


My staff:
C- Doumit
1b- D.Lee
2b- J.Lopez
3b- D.Wright
SS- Tulo
OF- Ordonez
OF-Ellsbury
OF-Hamilton
UTIL- Abreu
BN- C.Jackon
BN- J.Lowrie
BN- C.Figgins
BN- Church
BN- JD Drew
BN- R.Hernandez

SP- Wainwright
Sp- Pelfrey
SP-Bedard
SP-Peavy
SP- Haran
SP_F.Hernandez
RP- Soria
RP-Cordero
RP_ Sherill
BN- C.Young

[Seatownfavorite]

Not a chance.

Pedroia >> Peavy
R. Martin >> Doumit
Garza < Lopez Depending on how you look at it, not much a swing though in real value.

[RowdyRed]

I think the more accurate way to look at it is....

Peavy >>> Garza
Doumit << Martin
Lopez<<<Pedroia

So it depends on how bad the guy wants Peavy. He's losing the battle overall, but he may be willing to if his hitting is good enough to sustain a loss of Martin and Pedroia...particularly Pedroia.

That matches them up position by position....

[WhiteSoxPride]

Yea man if you can pull this off I definately would. Offer it and see if he bites.

[KriSpYY162]

I offered it... and i was also thinking of possibly taking out the catchers & adding RP since mine are kinda weak. I know he told me he needs a backup SS and another OF.....

Jose Lopez/Peavy/ JD Drew for Pedroia/Garza/Broxton?
(he also has for RP: K.Wood, Zeigler, Gregg, Capps)
(SP: Harden, Oswalt, Danks, Lester)

Lopez < Pedroia
Peavy>Garza
Drew ? Broxton