catcher question

[steamer33]

I'm new to fantasy & I'm playing in a 10 team - H2H - 5x5 - nonkeeper league. Someone in my league drafted 3 top catchers (McCann, Martin, Doumit). They just dropped Doumit. I wondering if I should drop Napoli for him, or instead drop Giambi? I took Giambi with my last pick & I already have decent HR guys, but I'm wondering if it's a good idea to carry 2 catchers & rotate?

C-Mike Napoli
1B-Derrek Lee
2B-Chase Utley
3B-Garrett Atkins
SS-Rafael Furcal
2B/SS - Aaron HIll
1B/3B - Aubrey Huff
OF-Ryan Braun
OF-Matt Holliday
OF-Many Ramirez
OF-Vernon Wells
OF-Coco Crisp
Util-Adam Lind
BN-Mark Reynolds
BN-Travis Snider
BN-Jason Giambi

SP-Dan Haren
SP-Daisuke Matsuzaka
SP-Edinson Volquez
SP-Ryan Dempster
SP-Erik Bedard
SP-Mark Buehrle
SP-Chris Carpenter
RP-Jonathan Broxton
RP-Frank Francisco

[Bonger]

Personally I'd drop Napoli for Doumit. Isn't Napoli splitting time with Mathis at C?

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=376931&p=3020296#p3020296

[Aberfoyle]

Yes definitely drop napoli for doumit. Doumit is one of the better hitters that just so happens to be a catcher.

[Neboguy]

Either one would be ok to drop, personally I'd drop Napoli too, Giambi has more power potential, but both will hurt your BA. Drop Giambi for somebody else . . . possibly a closer candidate.

[Les Straker's Toast]

Doumit is an upgrade and will play everyday because he can hit.