Tulo, Damon and CC for Reyes and Werth? WHIR!!!

[jonpistone2]

Im in a 10 team non keeper league, 5 x 5 with WEEKLY lineup changes...and 1pt per category (so you can get up to 10 pts each week)...we start all 8 fielders plus two more OFs, a Mid Inf, Corner Inf and Util....plus 9 P's of any kind....we also have a 7 player bench (22 starters and 29 total)

I was offered Tulowitzki, Damon and Sabathia for Reyes and Werth....clearly this is not a good deal for me...but i dont like simply rejecting trades...can anyone think of a good counter (even if its FAR in my favor)...or is there no such counter??? thanks!

My Team:
C - Victor Martinez
1B - Joey Votto
2B - D. Pedroia
3B - Aramis Ramirez
SS - Jose Reyes
2B/SS - Orlando Hudson
1B/3B - Chipper Jones
OF - Matt Holliday
OF - Ryan Ludwick
OF - Jayson Werth
OF - Xavier Nady
OF - Ryan Spilborghs
Util - Carlos Guillen
Bench - James Loney (1B)
Bench - Fred Lewis (OF)
Bench - Eric Byrnes (OF)
Bench - Jeremy Hermida (OF)
Bench - Jason Kubel (OF)

P - Jake Peavy (SP)
P - Jon Lester (SP)
P - Ryan Dempster (SP)
P - Gil Meche (SP)
P - John Danks (SP)
P - Hiroki Kuroda (SP)
P - Matt Capps (RP)
P - Joakim Soria (RP)
P - Joe Nathan (RP)
Bench - Andy Sonnanstine (SP)
Bench - Kenshin Kawakami (SP)

His Team:
C - J. Posada
1B - C. Delgado
2B - C. Utley
3B - M. Reynolds
SS - T. Tulowitzki
2B/SS - R. Cano
1B/3B - J. Giambi
OF - Vlad Guerrero
OF - S. Victorino
OF - J. Damon
OF - P. Burrell
OF - Ken Griffey Jr
Util - Ortiz
Bench - A-ROD
Bench - Jim Thome
Bench - AJ Pierzynski
Bench - Garret Anderson

P - CC Sabathia
P - Felix Hernandez
P - Zambrano
P - Randy Johnson
P - Chien-Ming Wan
P - Wakefield
P - M. Mussina
P - Chris Young
P - Carlos Marmol (RP)
Bench - Scott Baker
Bench - B. Arroyo
Bench - JC Romero (RP)

[Neboguy]

Do not accept this trade . . . a fair counter would be Reyes and Werth for Tulo, F.Hernandez, and Victorino. This way you don't lose too many steals and you get a stud SP in Felix Hernandez.

[dave knight]

No, you're giving away the two best hitters in my view. I'd just sit tight because you have a very balanced roster unless a much better deal comes a'callin.

Do not accept this trade . . . a fair counter would be Reyes and Werth for Tulo, F.Hernandez, and Victorino. This way you don't lose too many steals and you get a stud SP in Felix Hernandez.

Don't like this either, because now you're getting an even lesser pitcher than CC.

[Neboguy]

Actually, I'd rate Felix Hernandez pretty close to C.C. I'd bet King Felix puts up better numbers than Sebathia at the end of year . . .