Advice on trading Miguel Cabrera!!

[Aberfoyle]

I am in a 12 team roto league and have a manager that badly wants Miguel Cabrera. I am having trouble valuing him since he was my first round pick. I am not even sure if a trade would make sense with this manager as his team is relatively week. Here is a side by side of both our teams. I am in a 12 person rotisserie league, here is my roster:

C-Mike Napoli
1B-Carlos Pena
2B-Jose Lopez
SS-Furcal
3B-Miguel Cabrera
OF-Matt Holliday
OF-Magglio Ordonez
OF-Adam Dunn
Util-Berkman
BN-Felipe Lopez
BN-Tori Hunter
BN-Howie Kendrick

SP-Roy Halladay
SP-Feliz Hernandez
SP-Yovani Gallardo
SP-Kevin Slowey
SP-Jair Jurrjens
SP-Ian Snell
RP-BJ Tyan
RP-JJ Putz
RP-Trevor Hoffman
RP-Chris Ray

Here is his team:

C: Pierzynski
1B: adrian Gonzalez
2B: Cano
3B: Longoria
SS: Tulowitski
OF: Sizemore
OF: McLouth
OF: Pence
Util: Votto
Bench: Wieters
Bench: Ankiel

SP: Peavy
SP: Shields
SP: Wainwright
SP: Lowe
SP: Matt Garza
SP: Carmona
SP: Jered Weaver
RP: Percival
RP: Brandon Lyon
RP: Manual Corpas

[Darth Danielus]

How 'bout longoria/sizemore/sheilds FOR cabrera/hunter/gallardo....or something like that. Basically, take eva to replace m-cab, and then start coming up with other swaps you win until you feel comfortable. Find out just how badly the guy wants miggy...

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=376869

[mojoorising]

Swap 3 baggers and try and snag votto outta the deal by throwing in someone

[Midnight_Toker]

How 'bout longoria/sizemore/sheilds FOR cabrera/hunter/gallardo....or something like that. Basically, take eva to replace m-cab, and then start coming up with other swaps you win until you feel comfortable. Find out just how badly the guy wants miggy...

I was thinking something like this too. However, maybe trade a guy less valuable than Gallardo. I'm not a fan of that guys team either, so if I were you, I would definitely consider staying put for now.

Help me out?
viewtopic.php?t=376875

[Aberfoyle]

I went ahead and just offered him a trade for fun.

Longoria/Sizemore/Shields for Cabrera/Hunter/Slowey

Who wins in this deal? LOL

[Darth Danielus]

I'd say you win. Might even go so far as to call it a "crushing." The gap between sizemore and hunter is larger then the one between eva and m-cab. Taking sheilds is one hell of a cherry on top.

[Aberfoyle]

Okay I am back.. The trade was reject and he countered with

Evan Longoria
Robinson Cano
Fausto Carmona

for

Miguel Cabrera
Jose Lopez

[lastingsgriller]

i've got somne advise on trading Miguel Cabrera. don't trade Miguel Cabrera.

unless of course you can find a way to get seizmore and Longoria...

[WyldStallyn]

Okay I am back.. The trade was reject and he countered with

Evan Longoria
Robinson Cano
Fausto Carmona

for

Miguel Cabrera
Jose Lopez

insulting

mcab, magglio for sizemore, longoria would be pretty fair (though it doesnt help your team)

[Chicago RedSox]

Okay I am back.. The trade was reject and he countered with

Evan Longoria
Robinson Cano
Fausto Carmona

for

Miguel Cabrera
Jose Lopez

That's not good enough for Cabrera. I really don't think you should give him up unless you're overwhelmed, which isn't likely to happen considering his chips. Maybe ask Longoria/Shields for Cabrera/Slowey. He'll likely reject it, but I wouldn't trade Miggy for much less than that. Good luck