dave knight what do u think about this?WHIR

[fierro33]

ive been offered sizemore/josh johnson/huff for my hammilton and burnett

do i need more steals w sizemore? im starting mora at 3rd until arod comes back...is huff an upgrade?



10 team h2h 5x5 non keeper

C Ramon hernandez
1b Carlos pena
2b Brandon phillips
3b alex Rodriguez
ss jose reyes
OF josh hamilton
OF Manny Ramirez
OF Raul Ibanez
Util vernon wells
bench
Chris B young
lastings millege
melvin mora


Pitching

Jake Peavy
AJ Burnett
Scott Baker
kevin Slowey
Randy johnson
hiroki kuroda
Escobar


nathan
soria
bj ryan
morrow
capps
francisco
qualls
hoffman

[woowoo crew]

i would do this. while you're losing a good K pitcher in burnett, i really like josh johnson's potential this year. plus, you're getting sizemore... YES, do it.

help me out?? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=376452

[kidsilk]

Definitely do this deal. You are getting the best player in the deal plus a very underrated Josh Johnson. I like this a lot for you.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=376412

[fierro33]

anyone else

[fierro33]

will huff repeat last year?

[dave knight]

I don't really think much of Huff, I think he will be good for 20 not 30 HRs, but Sizemore should be similar to Hamilton except for 30 SB, no small feat, and Johnson has the potential to pitch as well as Burnett plus is in the weaker national league. I'd do the deal based on value and help to your team.

[fierro33]

dave do u see a significant difference in sizemores BA compared to hamilton? i have another offer on the table that is me giving up phillips and pena for adrian gonzo and roberts........which one is better?

[Midnight_Toker]

Well, I'm going to go against the grain here and say No.

Admittedly, I am a Hamilton homer and I just think with your lineup with Manny, ARod (once healthy), that is going to be very tough to beat along with Reyes, other key contributors ... Pena, Philips, etc. Sizemore will Def get you more steals, but you got Milledge on the bench, Philips will steal bases too. I think Hamilton will hit for higher avg, and slg, obp, ops.

Also, I dont know much about J. Johnson either.

[dave knight]

dave do u see a significant difference in sizemores BA compared to hamilton? i have another offer on the table that is me giving up phillips and pena for adrian gonzo and roberts........which one is better?

I'd rather do Phillips and Pena for Gonzo and Roberts, as I see Pena in the category of one hit wonder (although his 08 was decent, not great)...but Gonz is an elite hitter. This easily increases your power and steals, and you don't have to give up any pitching.

[Midnight_Toker]

What other FA 3rd basemen are available in your league?