First trade off the new season

[Surfs up]

We had our draft today. I am pretty well set with offense but my pitching isn't so great. I ad one manager approach me and ask if I would part with Tulo because he is weak in hitting and in the middle. When we do a trade the positions have to matchup. Looking at his team he has Peavy, Dempster and Harden as his top pitchers. I could use any of them but I doubt he would give up Peavy. What do you think of either Dempster or Harden and Punto. for Tulo and Trevor Cahill ?

[kidsilk]

It really depends on your roster but I would probably keep Tulo here. Punto is so much of a downgrade. It would be nice to add Harden but I would stick with what you have not seeing your lineup.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=376412

[Thracken]

I don't Tulo is a stud and Cahill is a top prospect who could do very well this year.

[Pythagoras]

Punto . It's tough to offer other suggestions w/o seeing your roster.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=376442

[dave knight]

It really depends on your roster but I would probably keep Tulo here. Punto is so much of a downgrade. It would be nice to add Harden but I would stick with what you have not seeing your lineup.

[Surfs up]

He also has Weeks. As I said his middle is weak.
Heres the est of my lineup
M. Cabrera
Utlley
Pujols
Wright
Reyes
Roberts
Tulo
Dye
Lewis
Snider
Bruce
Bay
Dukes
Overbay
Pierzynski
Verlander
Shields
Soria
Jurrigens
Wolf
Buehrle
Ray
Cahill
McDonald
I also have Price and lackey that Cahill and MacDonald replaced .

[Surfs up]

Anybody ese now that I have posted my roster?