Trade one of my 1B-Berkman, Fielder, or Gonzalez? WHIR

[bryan1327]

I have Berkman, Fielder, and A Gonzalez, he badly wants one of my 1st Basemen. With 2 UT slots I think right now I have the best two UT's going in the league.If I think about trading one, which one might you go for and what might you ask back in return? Or should i just stand pat?

He is asking for one 1B and SP...for a closer and maybe Phillips..what might you do?

12 team league..standard 5X5 HTH

My team..

C- V Martinez
1B- L Berkman
2B- R Cano
SS- J Reyes
3B- A Beltre
OF- H Pence, A Ethier, B Hawpe
UT-Fielder, Gonzalez
B- A Gordon, C Maybin, M Fontenot
SP- D Haren, S Kazmir, E Bedard, U Jimenez, J Danks, M Buehrle, K Kawakami, E Jackson
RP- H Bell, J Broxton, C Villanueva

His team..

C-M Napoli
1B- A Huff
2B- C Utley
3B- C Figgins
SS- J Rollins
OF- N Markakis, R Ludwick, N Cruz
UT- B Phillips, V Wells
B- C Snyder
SP- F Liriano, P Maholm, E Santana, A Harang, A Galarraga, T Wellemeyer, K Escobar
RP- J Valverde, B Jenks, F Cordero, M Capps, C Ray, B Marrow

[MadDog36]

Is Berkman OF eligible in your league?

Deal him Gonzalez/Cano for Philips/Morrow or Utley by himself then with the free spot add a solid RP or another OF.

You could use a stud OF as well as a closer and 3b upgrade.

I hope Gordon breaks out for ya.

Too bad he doesn't have an extra 3b.

Maybe you can get Ludwick on the cheap from his bad spring if you throw in Buehrle.

Offer him Gonzalez/Cano/Buehrle for Utley/Ludwick/Closer
Offer him Gonzalez/Cano for Utley/Ludwick or Cruz
(with the free spot add another SP)

Anyways, how many of htose players are bench (pitchers most likely).
Post some free agents in your league.

[bazzy_51]

I like Gonzo/Cano for Utley/Cruz if you can get it... i think Cruz is way underrated, i know hes 28, been to the big leagues twice and sent back down, but you can't deny his Minor league stats and im looking at a big sleeper year out of him, and most guys don't realize the potential in him so you can usually get him cheap... you need do need a big time OFer IMO and an upgrade at 3B, i wouldn't be OVERLY worried about your closer situation, at least you have 3 that are slated to close right now...

help me out...

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=376421

[dave knight]

Gonzo/Cano/Hawpe for Utley/Cruz might look better.