Pick a winner in this Miguel Cabrera deal?? WHIR ASAP! :)

[Millhouse]

10-team, 5x5 mixed roto keeper.

TEAM A GETS: M.Cabrera, Posada, Gallardo, Downs

TEAM B GETS: Morneau, Shoppach, Billinsgley, Broxton

Leave a link, WHIR as soon as humanly possible. Thanks.

[coma]

I personally like the Cabrera side, just because he is clearly the best player in the deal. Plus I figure Gallardo and Billingsley should have similar success. But without seeing the rosters for either team I like team A.

Help?
viewtopic.php?t=376335

[JRAMI]

I like team B better

[Berg]

Thanks for helping with mine.

That's a tough deal to call, but I like the Morneau side a bit more. Morneau is an RBI machine and isn't a huge drop from Cabrera, Shoppach has much better keeper value than Posada, and I give Billingsley and Broxton the edge over Gallardo and Downs.

[Carnac]

I like team B. Better all around talent. Best for your team? Don't know without roster.

[MNbaseball]

I agee team B gives you more all around value. team A has the best player, but nothing too great after that. It depends on what you need though so its tough to say without seeing your roster.

[dave knight]

MCab, Posada, Gallardo is better. Big boost in power over Morneau, Shoppach isn't as good as Posada and is probably fringe material, Gallardo could give you Billingsley-like line this year, so that seals the deal.