phillips/pena for adrian gonzo/roberts WHIR

[fierro33]

should i give up phillips/pena for gonzo/roberts?



numberswise(projections) i would be givng up 18 homers and 40 rbis but gaining 23 runs and 14 sbs with a higher BA



10 team h2h 5x5 non keeper

C Ramon hernandez
1b Carlos pena
2b Brandon phillips
3b alex Rodriguez
ss jose reyes
OF josh hamilton
OF Manny Ramirez
OF Raul Ibanez
Util vernon wells
bench
Chris B young
lastings millege


Pitching

Jake Peavy
AJ Burnett
Scott Baker
kevin Slowey
Randy johnson
hiroki kuroda
Escobar


nathan
soria
bj ryan
morrow
capps
francisco
qualls

[Amazinz]

Fairly close trade. Looks like one I'd be more apt to make in a Roto league where those 20 points of BA so valuable. In a H2H league, you're just not gaining enough to offset the loss in the two categories I value most.

[TheGuru22]

I think it is a trade I would make. You have enough power to offset the loss, and I think value wise the guys you are getting would be higher to use in future trade negotiations, as I think Gonzo is going to have a breakout season.

[dave knight]

I'd do the deal because you get more SBs without much of a drop in power.

[jmcampbe11]

I'd do this in a heartbeat if it is a roto league. Probably would pull the trigger in HtoH too. Pena is BY FAR the worst player in the deal.