Hamilton for Quentin/Others...WHIR

[pelvis_kick]

Here's the deal. It is a H2H yahoo league. 8-teams keeper. You keep one player at each positions, but no UTIL keeper, however you play 2 UTILs throughout the year. I am being offered my Hamilton (by a guy who really likes him and has him in another league we are in together) for his Carlos Quentin. I would also get either A) Jacoby Ellsbury or B)Shane Victorino and Adrian Beltre. I would also give up my third round pick next year. (Nothing crazy since we will keep 8 hitters/7 pitchers).
Offensive Cats: R, H, 2B, 3B, HR, RBI, SB, BB, K, TB, E, AVG, OPS
Pitching Stats: W, L, CG, SV, BB, K, GIDP, ERA, WHIP, K/BB, K/9, H/9, QS, BSV
(tons of cats, I know, not a fan.)

My team:
C - V-Mart
1b - A-Gon
2b - Kinsler
SS - S. Drew
3B - Chris Davis
OF - Manny
OF - Hamilton
OF - BJ Upton
UT - Chipper Jones
UT - David Ortiz
BN - Corey Hart
BN - Weiters
BN - Milledge
BN - Jay Bruce
BN - Felipe Lopez(we update daily, only backup at a few spots)

SP - Bills
SP - Kazmir
RP - Morrow
RP - Joba
P - Bedard
P - Capps
P - Volquez
BN - Qualls
BN - Lindstrom
BN - Oliver Perez
BN - Greinke
BN - Smoltz (gonna stash, 3 DL spots)
DL - Hoffman

Leave a link, WHIR.

[dave knight]

Quentin and Hamilton have each only done it once, so that is good value for you with Ellsbury.

[DaShiz23]

Quentin and Hamilton have each only done it once, so that is good value for you with Ellsbury.

With Ellsbury, very good deal indeed. The speed helps your team immensly.

[ayebatter]

On the surface it looks like a nice deal, but dude you have 6 good OFs as it is, Ortiz can only play at DH, you're not gonna sit Chipper, Davis is a stud so he'll be in your lineup, where the hell do ya think Ellsbury is gonna play when you have 5 spots for 8 guys. Pass