Hawpe and Marmol for Magglio?

[Berg]

5x5 using OBP. Is this a fair offer? Based on projections I've seen, Hawpe isn't much of a dropoff from Magglio, and if Marmol takes over as closer at some point his value would obviously rise significantly. Just looking for opinions - thanks, and WHIR.

[Houser33]

I like whoever is getting Hawpe and Marmol. Hawpe's in a position where he can get anywhere from 85-130 RBI's depending on the opportunities he gets. He is also ALOT safer when it comes to injuries and is actually better for OBP than Magglio. Marmol is definitely the wild-card here but since he can help your ERA, K's and WHIp regardless of where he pitches, I think you have to make this deal.

Mine: viewtopic.php?t=375554

[The Mighty Trow]

I like whoever is getting Hawpe and Marmol. Hawpe's in a position where he can get anywhere from 85-130 RBI's depending on the opportunities he gets. He is also ALOT safer when it comes to injuries and is actually better for OBP than Magglio. Marmol is definitely the wild-card here but since he can help your ERA, K's and WHIp regardless of where he pitches, I think you have to make this deal.

That summed it up quite nicely


me: viewtopic.php?t=376082

[DTChiefs]

I agree, much rather have those 2 than Mags!