Trade Quentin for which 1B? - WHIR

[Hit Factory]

I agree with the previous poster, if you could land Gonzalez/Beckett for Quentin/Hernandez I would do it without thinking twice! You would be upgrading at firstbase and you would gain a proven top tier pitcher, King Felix has major potential but he is such a crappy team don't expect very many wins.

[oxhammer]

There's enough concensus for Gonzalez/Beckett for Quentin/Hernandez. Hardest part of that is that the owner has won the league 2 years in a row...and is a Padres fan. Might be hard to get that one through.

As a backup plan, what do you guys think of Nady/Lester for Votto? This would allow me to pick up Duchscherer and stash him on my DL. I can also pick up Parra, Carmona, Wandy, or Buehrle in the meantime.

[saemick]

There's enough concensus for Gonzalez/Beckett for Quentin/Hernandez. Hardest part of that is that the owner has won the league 2 years in a row...and is a Padres fan. Might be hard to get that one through.

As a backup plan, what do you guys think of Nady/Lester for Votto? This would allow me to pick up Duchscherer and stash him on my DL. I can also pick up Parra, Carmona, Wandy, or Buehrle in the meantime.

I actually like this better. Votto will be a very nice 1B and you are really giving up nothing for him. You keep Quentin, upgrade at 1B, and keep your good SP.

thanks for helping with mine too

[MotorCityKitties]

I'd take the Quentin/Felix for Gonzalez/Beckett.

You'll have a SP surplus and can probably trade a SP with Nady for another OF.

I agree.

[NickyEyes]

I wouldn't trade quentin for fielder, but i do like the quentin/hernandez for gonzalez/liriano deal though. even for beckett instead of liriano is good too. its tough to tell if quentin is going to disappoint of do even better than last year. i think that trade is a good one for you.

[Eagle Baseball]

I like the Lester + a kicker for Votto deal.

[MemphisTigerFan10]

I'd take the Quentin/Felix for Gonzalez/Beckett.

You'll have a SP surplus and can probably trade a SP with Nady for another OF.

I totally agree!

Please help:
viewtopic.php?t=376005
viewtopic.php?t=376001

[cwhitty]

I wouldn't make any of those trades. Coco Crisp? Sit tight. Connor isn't that bad and there will be someone who emerges that you'll be able to plug in should you be dissatisfied with Connor.

[coma]

I personally wouldn't trade Quentin.. It would leave your OF pretty weak. But if you really wanted to I would do the 2nd trade.

Thanks for the help with mine!