Should I Pull the Trigger?

[Lockout]

I GET: Matt Holliday, Roy Oswalt
I GIVE: Jay Bruce, Josh Beckett

My Team:
C- Geovany Soto
1B- Ryan Howard
2B- Brian Roberts
3B- Chone Figgins
SS- Jimmy Rollins
OF- Jason Bay
OF- Jay Bruce
OF- Raul Ibanez
UTL- Rick Ankiel
Ben- Jeff Francoeur

SP- Brandon Webb
SP- Josh Beckett
RP- Brian Fuentes
RP- Frank Francisco
P- Troy Percival
P- Kevin Gregg
P- Ricky Nolasco
Ben- Zack Greinke
Ben- Javier Vazquez
Ben- Erik Bedard
Ben- Paul Maholm

[dave knight]

It's close, but I would side with the better hitter Holliday and National League pitcher Oswalt in this deal.

*though in a keeper I like the other side better.

[Lockout]

Any other thoughts? I'm leaning towards doing it but I'm just not sure about Bruce's upside and Oswalt's injury risk/falling numbers due to old age.

One thing to keep in mind is that our league has 6 hitting categories (including hits) and 4 pitching categories (dropping WHIP).

[j24jags]

It's close, but I would side with the better hitter Holliday and National League pitcher Oswalt in this deal.

*though in a keeper I like the other side better.

Agreed, in a keeper I'd want Bruce, but in a non-keeper, Holliday is definitely the safer/better pick.

viewtopic.php?t=375794

[RenPastana]

Keeper or not...take Holliday + Oswalt!

Holliday will not end the year in Oakland, oswalt pitches is one of the weakest hitting division in baseball!

help plz
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=376006