Trade involving Soriano and Beckett WHIR!

[chinch sacs]

Let me preface this with the statement that I NEED PITCHING! Whith that in mind, is this a good trade for me?

I GIVE:

A. Soriano, C. Davis, BJ Ryan & C. Young (SD)

I GET:

J. Beckett, J. Bruce and C. Kershaw

With the extra spot I will pick up 1 of these 3 RP:

C. Ray, M. Lindstrom or J. Mottes

What do you think?

Here is my roster, 6x6 extras are OBP and Holds:

C - V. Martinez.................. SP- C. Hamels
1B- A. Pujols..................... SP- D. Haren
2B- B. Roberts................... RP- J. Soria
3B- G. Atkins.................... P- BJ Ryan
SS- H. Ramirez.................. P- M. Capps
OF- BJ Upton..................... P- C. Qualls
OF- A. Soriano................... BN- Y. Gallardo
OF- B. Abreu..................... BN- C. Young
UT- C. Davis...................... BN- J. Cueto
BN- A. Ethier...................... BN- C. Carpenter
BN- R. Zimmerman
BN- J. Peralta
BN- J. Upton
BN- K. Johnson

[dave knight]

That's too much to give up for Soriano and Davis. You could possibly even get Sabathia or Santana for Soriano straight-up.

[Whosyomamma]

Thanks for the help on mine. You are definitely giving up too much! Try Soriano straight up for a Top 5 pitcher. Your team is stacked, is this an 8 team league?

[DaShiz23]

I would not want to give up that much offensive talent for those two pitchers.

[chinch sacs]

That's too much to give up for Soriano and Davis. You could possibly even get Sabathia or Santana for Soriano straight-up.

Unfortunately not. I tried the guys that had Sabathia, Santana and Webb... No dice.

[chinch sacs]

OK, I offered

Soriano, Ryan and Young

For

Beckett & Bruce

We'll see if if bites

[Mortician]

still dont like it

[DaShiz23]

me neither.

[rolltide1979]

nope...

what about mine?

viewtopic.php?t=375980