Should I trade Lee for Lackey? WHIR

[Da Rook]

Should I trade Cliff Lee, Ricky Weeks & Trevor Cahill for Lackey, Loney & Adam Dunn in my 5X5 League? And Why?

My Team
C - Martin
1B - Tex
2B - Roberts
SS - Reyes
3B - Aramis
OF - C.Lee, Holiday & Hunter
U - Burrell, Matsui
P - Peavy, Lee, Vazquez, Lowe, Meche, Big Unit, Wandy Rodriguez, Sommenstein, Cahill, Baker (Mariano, Valverde)
Bench: Weeks, Jacobs, Reynolds, Tavarez, Giles

**Leave Link - WHIR!!!

[grandpa]

Yes- because all three of the players you are getting are better then the 3 you are giving.

[Carnac]

I think it's a good trade for you. Dunn will give you power you need and Weeks will never see your starting lineup. Also Dunn's achilles heel, his average, will be offset by the rest of your team. Most of your players hit for high average. It's a great match.

Lee is likely to regress some this year and Lackey will be solid when he gets back from his injury. Your pitching is solid and can take the hit letting Lee and Cahill go. Loney is a throw in, but he does have some upside possibly. Just can't see him cracking your lineup.

Lee = Lackey might give Lee a slight edge based on last year
Dunn >>> Weeks

[joecahill]

I completely agree with Carnac here. Take this one and run.

[Da Rook]

Should I be worried about Lackey's injury lingering past May? Or even missing the season?

[dave knight]

I like it because of Dunn.