UPDATE/QUICK HELP NEEDED: Giving too much for MCab? WHIR!

[Millhouse]

**Guy made a counter offer, see bold additions under THE DEAL below...still good for me?**

5x5 mixed keeper.

THE DEAL
I give:
Justin Morneau, Jacoby Ellsbury, Ricky Nolasco & Jonathan Broxton

I get:
Miguel Cabrera, Matt Kemp, Paul Maholm & Scott Downs


Even though I hate the Broxton/Downs end, my gut says no-brainer for me if I can get the guy to take it, but you think it's good for me? And is it still worth it if it's Crawford over Kemp?

My team now:

C - Shoppach
1B - Howard
2B - Aviles
SS - Rollins
3B - Reynolds
MI - Jose Lopez
CI - Morneau
OF - Ellsbury, McLouth, Dye, Milledge, Burrell
UTIL - Maybin

SP: Webb, Liriano, Billingsley, AJ Burnett, Nolasco
RP: Broxton, Hanrahan, Francisco, Capps, Arredondo, Corpas

Thanks.... lv a link, WHIR.

[fantasysportsguy1210]

I do it since you're able to give up a closer without huting your staff. I do either Crawford or Kemp.

Please help:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=375857

[Zhangman1]

I'd def do the deal for either Crawford or Kemp

---
help on mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=375858

[maddog2020]

yeah, i'd definitely do this regardless if you get kemp or crawford, both upgrades over ellsbury and cabrera is a stud. plus, i don't know how great broxton will be this year, i'm in LA and he has his ups & downs, not the most reliable

thanks for the help w/ mine

[Millhouse]

bump for update. thanks.

[killertofu2222]

i'd do it. mcab>morneau....kemp/crawford>>>ellsbury

as much as i like nolasco, you wouldn't really be hurting your staff too much