beltran for bay/ibanez WHIR

[fierro33]

should i give up beltran for jason bay and raul ibanez?

10 team 5x5 H2H


C Mauer
1b Miguel Cabrera
2b Robinson Cano
3b Alex Rodriguez
ss Michael Young
of Carlos Beltran
of Carl Crawford
of Nate Mclouth
util Chris Davis

bench:

Lastings Miledge
Napoli

SP

CC Sabathia
Yovani Gallardo
Kevin Slowey
Ted Lilly
Josh Johnson


RP

brandon morrow
Carlos Marmol
kevin gregg
Matt Capps
Joel Hanrahan

[Amazinz]

I wouldn't. It would be a good deal if you needed to plug a hole. But since you don't I would keep Beltran who has the best value of the three.

[Hit Factory]

I agree with the previous poster, you don't really 2 outfielders in a trade. However if the other guy has a good second baseman you might see if he would package him with Bay, that would help to backup Cano incase he has another year similar to 2008.

[dooho]

i also agree. if you had a whole it would be great value for beltran, but since ibanez would just rot on your bench you need to keep the best player in the deal and that's beltran.

would you mind seeing mine?
viewtopic.php?t=375809

[Cypher74]

Agree with the others, keep Beltran since yuo can't use both. Unless you can swing one in another trade...

Help if you wouldn't mind?

viewtopic.php?t=375818