who do you like more?

[rasto21585]

in a dynasty league who would you take, chris c carter (oak) or carlos tiunfel (sea)?

[Guaranteed Loser]

Truinfel, it is not even close

[Omaha Red Sox]

Carter slightly over Triunfel.

[rasto21585]

is triunfel really that good?

[BeachBums]

1. triunfel
2. Carter

[Omaha Red Sox]

is triunfel really that good?

Not in my opinion. While he's young, he's got no power and he's not that good defensively so he'll likely move from the SS/2B positions, dropping his value drastically by the time he's a serviceable player.

Carter strikes out a lot and will always have a poor average, but his walks are decent and he's got a great power bat. Last season, over half of his hits went for extra bases. He's obviously a lot closer to the bigs too, being something like 4 years older than Triunfel.

[J35J]

I'd go with Triunfel here.

[Havok1517]

Triunfel based on position

[DevilDriver]

Triunfel

Not a fan of Carter, just another 1B with power but no contact skills.

[Omaha Red Sox]

I am really in the minority here.